Unknown Retired

Sherman D. Horton Jr.

Supreme Court of New Hampshire · Appointed 1990

Biography pending scraper ingestion.

Judicial record

28 opinions where Sherman D. Horton Jr. sat on the panel, spanning 1995–2000.

10 Majority authored
18 Joined majority

By court

  • N.H. 28

By disposition

  • Affirmed 17
  • Reversed 4
  • Mixed 3
  • Vacated 2
  • Dismissed 1

Panel votes per year

How Sherman D. Horton Jr.'s panel-seat count has shifted year by year. Overlaid with William F. Batchelder for comparison (drop the overlay).

0 4 8 12 16 20 1982 1987 1992 1997 2000 1995: 2 votes — Sherman D. Horton Jr. 1996: 2 votes — Sherman D. Horton Jr. 1997: 1 vote — Sherman D. Horton Jr. 1998: 1 vote — Sherman D. Horton Jr. 1999: 3 votes — Sherman D. Horton Jr. 2000: 19 votes — Sherman D. Horton Jr. 1982: 9 votes — William F. Batchelder 1983: 3 votes — William F. Batchelder 1984: 5 votes — William F. Batchelder 1985: 2 votes — William F. Batchelder 1986: 3 votes — William F. Batchelder 1987: 6 votes — William F. Batchelder 1988: 6 votes — William F. Batchelder 1989: 5 votes — William F. Batchelder 1990: 4 votes — William F. Batchelder 1991: 7 votes — William F. Batchelder 1992: 4 votes — William F. Batchelder 1993: 4 votes — William F. Batchelder 1994: 3 votes — William F. Batchelder 1995: 10 votes — William F. Batchelder 1997: 1 vote — William F. Batchelder 1999: 1 vote — William F. Batchelder
  • Sherman D. Horton Jr.
  • William F. Batchelder

Most-frequent co-panelists

Judges who appeared on the same opinions. aligned = same bucket (both majority, both dissent); partial = concurred in result but wrote separately; split = the meaningful disagreement (majority vs dissent).

Recent opinions

15 most recent opinions where Sherman D. Horton Jr. sat on the panel.

Docket Court Filed Disposition Case
99-173 N.H. 2000-11-20 Reversed Appeal of Flynn
98-233 N.H. 2000-11-17 Affirmed New Hampshire Boring, Inc. v. Adirondack Environmental Associates, Inc.
98-772 N.H. 2000-11-17 Affirmed Fassi v. Auto Wholesalers of Hooksett
99-384 N.H. 2000-11-17 Affirmed In re Samantha L.
98-643 N.H. 2000-11-17 Affirmed in part; reversed in part In re Floros
98-257 N.H. 2000-11-15 Affirmed Bergeron v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
98-153 N.H. 2000-11-15 Affirmed Simonsen v. Town of Derry
98-129 N.H. 2000-11-15 Affirmed in part; reversed in part Hanover Investment Corp. v. Town of Hanover
99-383 N.H. 2000-11-08 Affirmed State v. Duquette
98-698 N.H. 2000-11-02 — In re Mello
98-787 N.H. 2000-11-02 Reversed State v. Martin
97-819 N.H. 2000-10-31 Affirmed in part; reversed in part Averill v. Cox
97-840; No. 98-455 N.H. 2000-10-31 Affirmed State v. Rattee
98-393 N.H. 2000-10-16 Affirmed State v. Martin
97-087 N.H. 2000-10-05 Affirmed Bennett v. Lembo